
‘Silver Tongue’
The working theory of Silver Tongue is that an audience laughing hard enough will never ask where the map leads. For most of the night, the theory holds.
It helps that the people testing it are so good at their jobs. This world premiere from Miranda Middleton, Jacob Parker and Alec Steedman has spent years at the Hayes, and director Richard Carroll runs it like a man herding cats with cutlasses. It is Treasure Island with the gay turned up and the fourth wall taken out the back. Someone is on vocal rest. Someone else is calling out the dramaturgy. The theatre nerds in the room have clearly been waiting years for this.
Marty Alix is Jim, a bar janitor with a voice far too big for a mop bucket, pulled into the orbit of Billie Palin’s Silver Tongue. Palin plays a captain who would happily grab the world by its balls and would sooner drown than discuss the first mate who left. They click so fast it feels unrehearsed.
Then Jack Green arrives as a yacht captain assembled entirely from false bravado, greeting Jim with a new wrong name every time, and the room belongs to him. Natalie Abbott and Tana Laga’aia, as cabaret refugees whose unrequited love swells into a throuple, have a number that is the sharpest musical comedy of the night. Laga’aia moves between instruments like a man with a point to prove, and then proves it. Victoria Falconer, who also musically directs, gets a few minutes as a parrot and a flurry of feathers, and spends them like a millionaire.
Everything here is played live, cellos and accordions included, and nobody seems to be switching jobs when they pick one up. The songs lurch from rowdy shanty to something tender, starting with the hey ho of Down the Benbow. The storm is the best of the action, the ship heaving under an instrumental while Silver Tongue and Hands find their sea legs. Hailley Hunt’s pub and ship share one muted palette and almost no props, and somehow you always know where you are. Barrels and sails crowd the stage until you feel like freight.
The map, though, is decoration. The reveal arrives and the room nods politely, like a stranger has told it their name. The road from A to B is lined with good bits and ends nowhere in particular. The emotional climax is pushed so hard you notice the hand doing the pushing. The pace tips into pantomime, and a few jokes should have stayed in the green room. Yet the long unpicking of the B plots is a pleasure, because this lot are good company even when they are doing the washing up.
Bring the friend who heckles at pantomime and the one who owns a battered Stevenson. Leave the one who keeps asking what the stakes are at home.
The theory is mostly confirmed. The map leads nowhere, and by the end nobody has asked for directions.
Silver Tongue is running till 19 December at Hayes Theatre.




Leave a Reply