
New Rat Run Through Erskineville Rejected By Community
Story By Wendy Bacon and Andrew Chuter
A new road planned through Erskineville is angering residents and leading them to question the City of Sydney’s commitment to people-centred streets.
The City has approved plans to extend narrow MacDonald Street through to busy Mitchell Road to “allow traffic to enter and move through the precinct”.
However, the new road is not needed for property access. And analysis by UNSW transport planning expert Dr Chris Standen indicates that many residential streets in Erskineville and Newtown will become shortcuts between the nearby WestConnex motorway interchange, Euston Road, Erskineville Road and King Street.
In recent years, Erskineville’s Ashmore precinct has been redeveloped from industrial to residential, with the final stages set to be completed by property developer Coronation.
Friends of Erskineville (FOE) has been campaigning against the new through-road since November 2025, instead calling for an Ashmore Village Square with trees, outdoor dining and an active transport connection. More than 1200 residents have signed its petition.
The campaign was launched at a public meeting celebrating the 40th anniversary of the Erskineville ‘road wars’. In 1985, residents blockaded their narrow streets after the NSW government ordered temporary road closures to be reopened.
That campaign succeeded in making the closures permanent. Since then, Erskineville’s narrow residential streets have become relatively safe and quiet.
Responding to the MacDonald Street petition, the City held a public meeting at Erskineville Town Hall. The hall overflowed with concerned residents.
A motion from the floor calling on Council to pause the road and instead design a public space consistent with its Sustainable Sydney 2050 vision passed overwhelmingly.
Lord Mayor Clover Moore agreed to further meetings and said Council would seek a solution that was “predominantly for people and not for cars”.
A second meeting showed continuing opposition. Council presented alternative scenarios, including a road closure that would allow the space to be used as a civic plaza, and promised to review traffic-calming measures if the new road generated too much traffic.
But it gave no indication of how much additional traffic would be considered too much.
FOE subsequently conducted an online poll in which the plaza was the most popular option.
By August, however, Council’s position shifted from one of consultation to a Council ‘drop-in’ session informing residents that the road would proceed.
Council is relying on traffic studies dating back more than a decade. Asked for empirical evidence that opening MacDonald Street would not significantly increase through-traffic on streets west of Hadfields Street, the City pointed to modelling undertaken by Arup in 2005 and AECOM in 2013.
A City spokesperson said the “necessary traffic modelling and assessment” had been undertaken at each stage of the planning process, and said the 2013 study considered through-traffic impacts as well as traffic generated by the new development.
Residents argue that these studies are no longer an adequate basis for assessing the proposal. Both predate WestConnex and the St Peters interchange, as well as the growing emphasis on walking, cycling, public transport and reducing car dependence.
The reliance on these older studies also contrasts with the City’s own position during the WestConnex debate. In its submissions on the motorway, the City criticised traffic modelling and inadequate treatment of induced traffic, and sought additional modelling of impacts on areas including Erskineville, Alexandria, Green Square and Ashmore.
In 2016, Lord Mayor Clover Moore warned that the St Peters interchange would bring tens of thousands of additional cars into areas including Ashmore and Erskineville.
Long-term Erskineville resident Ellen O’Brien said access to the new apartments could still be provided from Mitchell Road without creating a continuous through-route.
“This could be a win/win situation – new apartments have access, Council fulfils its obligations to allow access, and the community gets a more walkable/cyclable thoroughfare, not a through road,” she said.
The dispute reached Council again on September 21, when Greens Councillor Matthew Thompson tabled the FOE petition and put a series of detailed questions to Council.
The answers confirmed that Council plans to collect traffic data six months after the road and signalised intersection open. But when asked what increase in traffic, crashes or injuries would trigger intervention, Council said there could be no single trigger or threshold.
Council also confirmed that turning the MacDonald Street extension into a pedestrian, cycling and emergency-vehicle connection instead would require the existing approvals to be modified and the Voluntary Planning Agreement (VPA) with the developer varied.
Coronation, however, says it has already raised the possibility of changing the VPA. When interviewed, Coronation’s Head of Urban Transformations, Aras Labutis, was asked whether it could be amended. While he said the specific issue of MacDonald Street had not been discussed, Coronation had asked whether the VPA could be changed.
“We’ve absolutely asked the question about amending the VPA,” Labutis said. “And we have been told, in no uncertain terms, that it was actually not changing. We’re really bound by that … we have been told they are not going to entertain that.”
The City has also made its position explicit. In response to questions, a City spokesperson said: “We cannot require the developer to vary the planning agreement, nor do we want to.”
Yet the same VPA is currently being varied for another part of the development, with the City notifying residents in October of a proposed amendment to the alignment and extent of Alpha Street.
Dr Standen disputes the City’s claim that its earlier studies adequately assessed the through-traffic consequences of opening MacDonald Street.
“Early council reports relating to the precinct did warn of increased rat-running. But the subsequent traffic studies assessed only local traffic generated by the new development. The City neglected to model the additional through-traffic generated by connecting Macdonald Street to Mitchell Road and Maddox Street,” he said.
City of Sydney planners at the recent drop-in confirmed that no predicted traffic volumes have been modelled for MacDonald Street.
Dr Standen said his own modelling showed the new route could be up to seven minutes faster than using main roads and avoid up to five sets of traffic lights.
“That would create a strong incentive for navigation apps and drivers to use this new rat-run,” he said.
Forty years after Erskineville residents fought successfully to reclaim their streets from through traffic, they are asking the City to build on that legacy rather than undo it.
Andrew Chuter is the President of Friends of Erskineville and Wendy Bacon was previously the Professor of Journalism at UTS and is a member of FOE.



