
Evidence has concluded in Beau Lamarre-Condon’s double murder trial, with closing arguments expected to begin this week before the jury considers its verdicts.
The former NSW police officer has pleaded not guilty to murdering Jesse Baird and Luke Davies at Baird’s Paddington home on February 19, 2024. He maintains the men died during two separate struggles involving his police pistol.
Evidence concluded on Monday (Nov 16), following days of cross-examination of Lamarre-Condon, and a final round of questions from his own barrister. The prosecution then presented its final evidence in reply.
What happens on Thursday?
Justice Natalie Adams told jurors the court would not sit on today or Wednesday (Nov 17-18), with closing addresses expected to start on Thursday.
Crown prosecutor Brett Hatfield SC will put the prosecution’s final arguments to the jury. Defence barrister John Stratton SC is anticipated to deliver his address on Monday, November 23, with deliberations expected next week, although this still remains an estimate.
Before deliberations, the judge will explain the relevant law and how jurors should approach their decisions.
Lamarre-Condon does not have to prove his innocence; the prosecution must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
What are the competing accounts?
The Crown alleges Lamarre-Condon entered the terrace disguised as a food delivery rider, shot Baird twice in the kitchen, then shot Davies through a bedroom door to eliminate a witness.
Lamarre-Condon says he went there to collect belongings and wore a motorcycle helmet to avoid being recognised.
He told the court Baird lunged at him with a knife, and that he deliberately fired the first shot to disarm him. His account is that another shot discharged during their struggle.
He says Davies subsequently obtained the pistol and died when it discharged during a second struggle, maintaining his own finger was not on the trigger.
Lamarre-Condon’s fiery cross-examination
During cross-examination, Hatfield repeatedly challenged Lamarre-Condon’s explanation for both deaths.
“You executed him with that second shot,” Hatfield put to him , about Baird.
“I never executed Jesse Baird,” Lamarre-Condon replied.
Hatfield then put to him that his actions were inconsistent with manslaughter and amounted to murder, and directly accused him of murdering both men.
“You murdered Jesse Baird didn’t you?” Hatfield asked.
“I did not,” Lamarre-Condon answered.
“You then murdered Luke Davies to eliminate him as a witness,” Hatfield said.
“I did not,” Lamarre-Condon replied.
Hatfield also challenged the account of Baird producing a knife, suggesting Lamarre-Condon had constructed that explanation after seeing material in the prosecution brief.
Lamarre-Condon’s relationship with Baird, and his behaviour after their involvement ended, occupied a substantial part of cross-examination.
He admitted lying to Baird and gaslighting him over an Instagram story suggesting Baird had sent him flowers. The court heard the post was made visible to one person, whom Lamarre-Condon considered a romantic rival.
He also conceded falsely denying that he had blocked that man on Baird’s phone.
But he rejected allegations of stalking and obsession, including the Crown’s suggestion he used Snapchat’s location function to track Baird and engineer running into him.
“Smitten, yes, obsessed, no,” he told the court.
Lamarre-Condon also rejected Hatfields claims he watched Baird have sex with another man while standing outside his bedroom window, saying he went there to collect belongings and left as soon as he realised Baird was having sex. Hatfield said he was “stalking him,” to which Lamarre-Condon replied “I disagree.”
When questioned during cross-examination about the aggravated break and enter charge, Lamarre-Condon told the court he intended to take Baird’s phone outside to look through his messages while he slept, but panicked when Baird woke and ran away with his phone and wallet.
The prosecution als questioned whether purchases, enquiries, and messages sent to friends before February 19 showed preparation.
The purchases included a SIM card registered under the false name Bob Ballard, surfboard bags later used to transport the bodies, and an online purchase Hatfield suggested was a motorcycle helmet – the latter of which Lamarre-condon said was a laser hair removal kit.
Hatfield questioned Lamarre-Condon about cleaning the property, moving the bodies and using Baird’s phone.
Lamarre-Condon agreed he sent messages from Baird’s phone to give the impression Baird remained alive.
He also accepted his actions after the shootings were strategic, but maintained they align with his belief the deaths were manslaughter rather than murder.
What else has the jury heard?
Earlier evidence included a short Triple Zero call made from Davies’s phone. Jurors heard muffled audio and were told two police callbacks went to voicemail.
The Crown says Davies made the call while seeking help. Lamarre-Condon says he made it after Baird was shot.
Jurors visited the Paddington terrace and viewed a reconstruction showing possible firing angles. They heard about blood identified as belonging to both men, a bullet recovered beneath the kitchen, and a hole discovered in a bedroom door.
A detective described finding the bodies in surfboard bags near Bungonia. The court heard allegations of an earlier unsuccessful attempt to sink them in a dam using concrete and weights.
A friend, whose identity is suppressed, testified that Lamarre-Condon confessed to shooting two people and said he could not leave a witness. Recordings captured Lamarre-Condon later telling him he had misheard or misinterpreted that account.
What was the final evidence?
On Monday (Nov 17), Lamarre-Condon maintained he had never purchased a motorcycle helmet and said he used his own details when hiring a van.
The Crown then read statements from Baird’s brother, who said he found no surfboard in Baird’s ute when collecting it in April 2024, and no damage consistent with its fuel cap being forced open. Those statements followed Lamarre-Condon’s earlier statements about retrieving a surfboard and previously pouring water into the petrol tank of Baird’s vehicle.
The final evidence also included a statement from Davies’s mother, Sandra Davies, confirming her son was right-handed. That detail was relevant to Lamarre-Condon’s account of the second struggle: he had told jurors Davies held the pistol in his left hand, with his left index finger on the trigger, and that he turned Davies’s left wrist away before the gun discharged.




Leave a Reply